A snow-covered house with white siding and partial stone facade.

Asphalt Shingles and Metal: A Quick Comparison

asphalt-shingles-and-metal-a-quick-comparison_6068991d1274e.jpeg

If you’re planning a roof replacement this season, you’ll need to choose an excellent material. After all, your new roofing’s longevity and overall performance will depend on your choice. Two of the most popular roofing options today are asphalt shingles and metal. But which one is best for your home and needs?

Strength

Taking on extreme weather conditions is not a problem with asphalt shingles and metal roofing. The former is coated with protective mineral granules that help it withstand the harshest elements. The latter can also deliver the superior weather protection, but at a slightly better rate. 

Versatility

Both asphalt shingle and metal roofing can help your home make a bigger impression from the curb, although in slightly different ways. Asphalt shingles, for example, look beautiful on traditional homes, such as Colonial, Craftsman, Farmhouse and Victorian. Metal roofing, meanwhile, matches well with Contemporary and Modernist homes. But customization is never an issue with the two. Both are available in a wide selection of colors and profiles – with asphalt shingles even emulating the natural beauty of a wood shake roof – allowing for many design possibilities. 

Longevity

When installed and maintained correctly, a metal roofing system can last up to 50 years. Asphalt shingles have a shorter lifespan – up to 25 years – but they are easier to install, repair and maintain. Both roofing options generally come with solid warranty coverage to provide an additional layer of protection to your investment.

Energy Efficiency

Both roofing options can help keep your summer cooling bills to a minimum. Some asphalt shingles are available with cutting-edge cooling technology to prevent attic heat buildup and ensure a cooler, more comfortable indoor environment. Metal roofing can do the same thing with its inherent reflective properties. When augmented with a light color, a metal roof can block solar heat radiation, helping keep your home cool and pleasant. 

Look no further than Safe Harbor Exteriors for all your roof replacement needs. We serve the areas in and around Shawnee and Kansas City, KS. Call us today at (913) 553-3620, or fill out this contact form to schedule your consultation.

Get a Free Estimate

Latest Blog Posts

If woodpeckers are making themselves at home in your siding, drilling holes to create a place to nest or gather insects for their next meal, your home’s protective layer is now vulnerable to costly moisture damage. ..

essential-features-of-a-secure-front-door.webp

Choosing the right material is one of the most significant decisions homeowners face during a window replacement project...

durable-window-frame-material.webp

When homeowners ask us about upgrading their windows, one of the most common questions we hear is, “Are triple-pane windows worth the extra cost...

triple-pane-windows-Kansas-City.webp

Reviews

We talked to multiple companies while deciding who to use for the exterior of our home. Safe Harbor was transparent, fast, and offered James Hardie siding compared to all the other companies only offering vinyl. Safe Harbor was much more affordable than many of the other companies, who just wanted as much money as possible. We are extremely happy with our siding, soffit, fascia, flashing, gutters, windows and the guarantee that comes with their work. If there was any more work to be performed, without a doubt, we would chose safe Harbor again.

James W.

Safe Harbor installed James Hardie siding, soffits, and gutters. The install was meticulous and our home was left cleaner than when the company showed up. The level of detail in the install was beyond expectation! We are so pleased with the quality of the work and the professionalism of the install team!

Carolyn P.
The Google "G" logo.
5.0
Rating
The Facebook "F" logo.
4.9
Rating
The GuildQuality logo.
4.9
Rating
A badge for a Better Business Bureau (BBB) Accredited Business.
A+
Rating

Trusted Brands & Partners

An "Elite Preferred" badge from James Hardie.
The logo for Fiberon.
The logo badge for a GAF Master Elite Gold certified contractor.
A "Master Shingle Applicator" logo badge from CertainTeed.
A logo badge for an award for service excellence from GuildMaster.
The logo for Pella.
The logo for ProVia.
The logo for Marvin.
The RainDrop Pro Gutter Guard logo.
The EZ Gutter Guards logo.
The logo for DECRA Metal Roofing.
The logo for DaVinci Roofscapes.
The Owens Corning logo.
The CertainTeed logo.

Contact Us

A house with new siding and roofing with the Safe Harbor Exteriors logo superimposed on the left side.

Address
11009 Johnson Dr.
Shawnee, KS 66203
Get Directions
© 2025 Safe Harbor Exteriors. All Rights Reserved